Old Time Mystery Radio | Old Time Radio

Old Time Mystery Radio | Old Time Radio

Old Time Mystery Radio | Old Time Radio brings you classic mystery, suspense, crime, and psychological drama from the golden age of radio. Enter stories of murder, deception, strange circumstances, hidden motives, dangerous secrets, and unexpected twists. Each episode is an Old Time Retro Radio production, presenting the original broadcast with gently cleaned and mastered audio, a newly produced introduction and closing, and custom episode artwork. Featuring memorable mysteries, atmospheric suspense, detective tales, and dramatic performances, Old Time Mystery Radio celebrates the storytelling that made classic radio unforgettable. Rediscover classic old time radio mystery, suspense, crime drama, detective stories, psychological thrillers, and vintage radio.












Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/old-time-mystery-radio-old-time-radio--7217889/support.
00:00
00:00

Episode's summary

In this episode of Nick Carter, Master Detective, a young veteran named Steve Evans attempts to become a detective by offering $800 to Nick Carter. The investigation into a safe burglary at United Veterans Incorporated reveals that a list of 20,000 names was stolen, potentially to scam veterans. As Nick investigates, he discovers that Steve's father, Laurie Evans, has been murdered and implicated in the crime. Nick Carter executes an elaborate plan involving radio broadcasts and staged escapes to lure Malone into revealing the stolen names list. Following a tense confrontation where Steve Evans survives an assassination attempt, the truth behind the 'missing thumb' ruse is revealed, and Nick explains how he used bait to track Malone to his office.

Chapters

Click on a chapter to go directly to that moment

Highlights

It's 800 bucks cash. All I saved in the army. What's it for? I decided I'm going to learn how to be a detective.

00:04:55 · Steve Evans offers his life savings to Nick Carter as an entrance fee to become a detective.

The only thing he lifted? The magazine subscription list. He stole 20,000 names and addresses.

00:06:20 · Sergeant Matheson reveals the specific target of the burglary was a list of veteran names.

There's a handprint on it. A right hand with a thumb missing.

00:13:13 · Nick discovers a physical clue at the crime scene that links the perpetrator to the missing thumb mentioned in the title.

Your local station has kindly consented to relay this announcement to help in the search for Steve Evans, suspect in the murder of a watchman at Irving Place, and his father, Laurie Evans, in a hardware store in Brooklyn.

00:15:49 · Nick Carter uses a radio broadcast to spread false information about Steve Evans to manipulate Malone's curiosity.

So instead of looking for him, I made him look for me and lead me to the stolen names.

00:25:31 · Nick Carter explains the logic behind his complex strategy of using Steve as bait.

Episodes

249-

Nick Carter, Master Detective - "The Case of the Missing Thumb" (1947)

In this episode of Nick Carter, Master Detective, a young veteran named Steve Evans attempts to become a detective by offering $800 to Nick Carter. The investigation into a safe burglary at United Veterans Incorporated reveals that a list of 20,000 names was stolen, potentially to scam veterans. As Nick investigates, he discovers that Steve's father, Laurie Evans, has been murdered and implicated in the crime. Nick Carter executes an elaborate plan involving radio broadcasts and staged escapes to lure Malone into revealing the stolen names list. Following a tense confrontation where Steve Evans survives an assassination attempt, the truth behind the 'missing thumb' ruse is revealed, and Nick explains how he used bait to track Malone to his office.

17 Oct 2026
248-

Suspense - "The Mystery of Edwin Drood, Part Two" (1953)

This episode concludes the radio adaptation of 'The Mystery of Edwin Drood.' The investigation into Neville Landless's arrest reveals bloodstains on his person, leading to a dramatic confrontation where Rosa reveals her true love for Neville and her loathing for John Jasper. As the mystery reaches its climax, Mr. Jasper experiences a psychological breakdown while confronting evidence that challenges his sanity. The story concludes with Landless confronting Jasper at the crypt, resulting in Jasper's arrest, followed by production credits.

16 Oct 2026
247-

Richard Diamond, Private Detective - "The Betty Moran Case" (1949)

In this episode of Richard Diamond, Private Detective, investigator Richard Diamond is hired by William Moran to investigate a blackmail ring following the death of Moran's wife, Betty. Following leads from the police precinct to Skid Row, Diamond uncovers connections to Mac Grayson and Leo Fink. As the investigation deepens, Diamond tracks the murder of Leo Fink to a hitman named Louis Osgood. A tense confrontation on a Staten Island ferry leads to Moran's confession that he murdered his wife and orchestrated the blackmail scheme. The episode concludes with a romantic moment between Rick and Helen followed by the program's closing credits.

15 Oct 2026
246-

The New Adventures of Nero Wolfe - "Dear Dead Lady" (1950)

The investigation into the murder of Ilsa Dana begins when Theodore Oliphant seeks protection for her, only for Archie Goodwin to discover her body in her apartment. As Nero Wolfe navigates mysterious visitors and financial struggles, he examines suspects including Barstow Young and Jack Hunter. Through deductions involving a Shakespearean quotation, a marriage license, and a hidden presence in the victim's apartment, Wolfe identifies the boxer Jack Hunter (Johann Jäger) as the killer. The case concludes with the revelation of the victim's manipulative nature and the arrest of her secret husband.

14 Oct 2026
245-

The Adventures of Philip Marlowe - "The Big Step" (1950)

Private investigator Philip Marlowe is hired by Betty Cantor to find her friend Shirley Vitello, who disappeared following a frightening newspaper report. As Marlowe investigates Shirley's workplace and her husband Gilbert's studio, he uncovers evidence of a missing gun and a mysterious connection to a rival chemist, Morris Dennecker. While the case initially appears to be a suicide at the Redondo Fishing Pier, Marlowe uses clever deduction regarding background noise heard during a phone call to reveal that Shirley was actually murdered. He concludes that her husband, Gilbert, conspired to stage her death as a suicide to keep the proceeds from their shared crimes.

13 Oct 2026